Showing posts with label Miracles. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Miracles. Show all posts

Saturday, January 14, 2023

Answered Prayer Fallacy

All religious belief is unsupported by objective evidence. Religious people who believe in divine intervention usually claim that their prayers are answered by God. Since physics tells us that the Laws of nature are regular and fixed and if they were subject to intervention by a God (miracle?), we would expect dramatic effects within our reality. Science has never confirmed any such event and since such would be an extraordinary event requiring extraordinary evidence, it is reasonable to conclude that prayer effects are most likely the result of the fallacy of Post Hoc Ergo Propter (After this, therefore because of this): correlation interpreted as causation. Regarding the claims of medical miracles, the realities of spontaneous remission and unusual events are ignored.

Sunday, January 1, 2023

Faith Healers: They Know It's A Scam

"Certain conditions faith healers avoid like the plague. Here are a list of things faith healers will never attempt to heal because they always fail spectacularly. While pastors and prophets like Benny Hinn, Alph Lukau, and Kenneth Copeland will often make grand claims about their healing powers and tell elaborate tales of the miracles they've seen and performed, most of their stunts all have one thing in common. Let's explore the trend and see what exactly faith healers will and won't attempt to heal and why."

Click on the link below for a 10-minute video focused on the types of issues these charlatans will not touch:


Friday, April 24, 2020

Miracles

"A miracle is an event not explicable by natural or scientific laws. Such an event may be attributed to a supernatural being (God or gods), a miracle worker, a saint or a religious leader."     https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miracle


It is virtually universal that all religions based on an interventionist deity accept miraculous claims.  In such cases, eyewitness testimony's value is inflated, as scientific scrutiny has failed to support the reality of any miracle.  This link is a textbook example of overselling the importance of eyewitness testimony by a religious apologist:    http://www.toughquestionsanswered.org/2015/08/24/why-was-hume-wrong-about-miracles-part-2/?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+ToughQuestionsAnswered+%28Tough+Questions+Answered%29

This link concisely presents the reality of miracle claims from a science-based perspective:  http://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Miracle

Joe Nickell, a noted skeptic, wrote this article for The Secular Web:
Examining Miracle Claims

The Skeptic Dictionary addresses the Catholic claims of incorruptible saints:
Incorruptible Body

John W Loftus does a good job of defining miracles and looking at them from biblical times to today here, and also does a good job in exposing the dishonesty of apologetics. He has a nice summary here also.

Rationality Rules clearly and succinctly debunks miracles here.

A final challenging thought for anyone who accepts miracles: 
  • Miracles, if they actually occur, are suspensions of the laws of nature.
  • Science depends on strict regularity of the laws of nature for its success.
  • Science works.

Friday, April 10, 2020

Miracles Of Lourdes?

When interacting with Catholic Christians over the topic of miracles, the "miracles" at Lourdes, France usually are presented. Following are quotes and links on the topic:

"Of all the cures alleged to have occurred at Lourdes, however, none have involved dramatic, unambiguous events like the growing back of a severed limb. Belgian philosopher Etienne Vermeersch likened this fact to the lack of clear, unambiguous data in support of the existence of Bigfoot or the Loch Ness monster. He also claimed that there have probably been significantly more fatal accidents suffered by pilgrims on their way to or from Lourdes than there have been cures."

Lourdes - The Skeptic's Dictionary

"Some 1,200 cures were said to have been observed between 1858 and 1889, and about one hundred more each year during the “Golden Age” of Lourdes, 1890–1914. We studied 411 patients cured in 1909–14 and thoroughly reviewed the twenty-five cures acknowledged between 1947 and 1976. No cure has been certified from 1976 through 2006." (amazing what you find as scientific analysis improves)

The Lourdes Medical Cures Revisited

"While the Catholic church teaches that God sometimes performs miracles, including cures, which doctors cannot explain, sceptics reject this as unscientific and explain that sudden recoveries as psychological phenomena or the delayed result of earlier treatment."

Lourdes finds the cure for lack of miracles: a less strict definition

"The new criteria shift the focus from scientific inquiry — can doctors explain it or not? — to a religious appreciation of the spiritual experience linked to improbable healing."

No new Lourdes miracles despite eased criteria

"No one is suggesting that the area was bone dry, of course. The photographs (such as they are for being a century old and poorly exposed) do seem to show overcast skies, and it’s perfectly plausible that there had been light rain that morning. But that’s a far cry from the claim that the pilgrims and land were “soaked,” and this discrepancy could easily account for why people’s clothes were—or seemed to be—dryer than they might have expected."

Fatima Miracle Claim All Wet

Saturday, December 21, 2019

There IS A Proper Way To Do History

Among Richard Carrier's skills is the ability to communicate what is involved with the Historical Method:
This hour-long presentation delves into the subject in a logical and understandable manner:
Miracles and Historical Method
- - - - - - -

NOTE: John W Loftus, an atheist author who has earned three master’s degrees from Lincoln Christian Seminary and Trinity Evangelical Divinity School. Loftus, a former student of noted Christian apologist William Lane Craig, got some of the biggest names in the field to contribute to this book, which represents a critical analysis of the very idea of miracles.

Saturday, October 19, 2019

What To Make Of "Eucharistic Miracles"?

If you are not Catholic, this term may not be known to you. If so, here is a link explaining eucharistic miracles.

To clarify, miracle is an event not explicable by natural or scientific laws. Such an event may be attributed to a supernatural being (especially a deity), magic, a miracle worker, a saint, or a religious leader. (link). So, for science to accept ANY miracle is a very high bar indeed (link, link). For further information on miracles in general, here is a link to all of my posts addressing the topic. 

Now, let's look at some of the many examples of supposed eucharistic miracles. Below are several links in support of these phenomena:

Thursday, March 14, 2019

The "Best" Documentation For Miracles Debunked

The Lead Apologist for Catholic Answers, the top Catholic apologetics media in the USA, was asked on a recent podcast to provide the best resource in support of miracles. He quickly said, THIS book:
Miracles: The Credibility of the New Testament Accounts by Craig Keener. Below is a 9-part review of the claims made in this extensive book:









Saturday, October 1, 2016

A Look At Miracles As Described By Other Than Christianity

Since deconverting from Catholicism, I have noticed a lack of recognition of the validity of miracle stories in faiths other than Christianity.  Virtually all religions have similar stories about miracles.  A question for Christians:  does your god also perform miracles within other faiths?

Following are a few link showing the religious universality of miracles.  Now please support with evidence, not only the validity of miracles, but that Christianity has a lock on them.  Oh, they don't?  Then you have some 'spaning to do.

What Do the World’s Religions Say About Miracles?

Miracle

Buddhist Miracle

Richard Carrier's Take

Friday, September 2, 2016

The Credulity Of NPR Regarding Miracles

"If the Catholic church believes that saints are pipelines to God who can provide special cures, how come prayer to saints hasn’t restored lost eyes or amputated limbs? Why is it only diseases known to spontaneously regress that the incipient (or established) saints can “cure”? Isn’t that a remarkable coincidence?"

NPR touts Mother Teresa’s “miracles”

Wednesday, August 31, 2016

Are They Miracles Or Natural Spontaneous Remissions?

With the soon-to-be Sainthood of Mother Teresa comes discussion of how someone is declared a Saint by the Catholic Church.  Traditionally, for an individual to be declared a Saint, two "certified" miracles must be credited to prayer directed to the prospective Saint.  Left out of the Church's declaration regarding these miracles is skeptical consideration of the natural and frequent phenomenon of spontaneous remission of medical problems, to include serious forms of cancer.

A Look At Mother Teresa As She Becomes A Saint

"How rational is Catholicism, and how rational is this phony, cooked-up way of declaring that some person gets a special telephone line to God?"

" - - - the legend of Agnes Bojaxhiu is impervious to fact, just as Catholicism itself is impervious to fact."

Saturday, August 20, 2016

Gullibility + Church Economics = "Supernatural" Visions And Healings

"Michael O’Neil, a miracle researcher and author who runs the website MiracleHunter.com, told CNA that the approval is significant. It means that the messages from the apparitions are not only approved for the faithful to read, he explained: the bishop is saying the events were in fact actual miraculous apparitions."

As a skeptic, I am ready to accept all of this as "supernatural" with sufficient evidence.  What do we have here?

Wednesday, July 20, 2016

The Uri Geller Defense Of Miracles

"We can’t prove that the Bible’s miracle claims aren’t for real, despite all the precedents, but that’s the way to bet. The plausible natural explanation makes the supernatural explanation unappealing and unnecessary. Only someone with a desire to support a preconception wouldn’t follow the evidence where it leads.

Insights into Bible Miracles from Magician Uri Geller

Wednesday, June 15, 2016

Miracle Cancer Cures

Throughout history, religious people from many traditions have claimed "miracle" cures from cancer and other diseases.  This article highlights the natural causes of such.

Why Do Some Cancers Disappear?

The "miracles" supposedly coming out of Lourdes, France offer challenges to science-based thinkers, however - - - (link)

Labels


Click on image

Choose how you look at reality wisely. Yes, it is a binary choice.

Choose how you look at reality wisely. Yes, it is a binary choice.
Click on image